Is Inn at Bay Harbor worth it? Honest pros and cons

Yes — Inn at Bay Harbor is a solid choice if you want a lakefront resort with on-site dining, a seasonal outdoor pool, year-round hot tub, spa services, and a mix of hotel rooms and larger Cottages. It fits families and couples looking for waterfront access and onsite activities, though expect mandatory resort fees and some extra charges for spa services and add-ons.
In this guide
Location and how to get there
Inn at Bay Harbor sits on Little Traverse Bay (Lake Michigan) at 3600 Village Harbor Drive in the Bay Harbor/Petoskey area with direct lakefront access and a private sandy beach. The property offers waterfront access, on-site trails, and close connections to local shops and the Great Lakes Center for the Arts.
The property provides shuttle and valet services as part of its Resort Activities Fee; if you need transfers to off-property destinations or regional ferry services to islands, check with the resort concierge for current options and schedules.
- Private sandy beach and lakeside lawn
- Resort shuttle service included within a five-mile radius (as part of the resort fee)
- On-site bike rentals and access to the Little Traverse Wheelway
| Nearby spot | How to reach from the resort |
|---|---|
| Great Lakes Center for the Arts | Short walk |
| Village at Bay Harbor (boutiques, marina) | Walkable waterfront area |
| Bay Harbor Golf Club / Crooked Tree Golf | Contact concierge for access and arrangements |

Rooms, Suites and Cottages — what to expect
Room types range from Standard Room (Quarry View) and Grand Room, Lake View to Suite, Lake View (Master) and several Cottage options including Cottage, 3 Bedrooms (Crooked Tree) and Cottage, 3 Bedrooms, Lakeside. Expect a mix of standard hotel rooms and larger suite/cottage layouts with kitchenettes in many units.
Breakfast for two is included with standard stays. Specific bedding mixes are listed for each room type — for example, Grand Room, Lake View is offered as 1 King Bed or 2 Queen Beds; Cottage, 3 Bedrooms (Crooked Tree) includes 1 King Bed, 1 Queen Bed, 2 Twin Beds and 1 Queen Sofa Bed.
- Room names to note: Grand Room, Lake View; Suite, Lake View (Master); Grand Room (Quarry View); Standard Room (Quarry View)
- Cottage choices: Cottage, 2 Bedrooms, Lakeside; Cottage, 3 Bedrooms (Crooked Tree); Cottage, 3 Bedrooms, Lakeside
- Many suites and Cottages include kitchenettes or dining areas
| Room type | Typical bed setup |
|---|---|
| Grand Room, Lake View | 1 King Bed or 2 Queen Beds |
| Suite, Lake View (Master) | 1 King Bed, 1 Queen Murphy Bed, 1 Queen Sofa Bed |
| Cottage, 3 Bedrooms (Crooked Tree) | 1 King Bed, 1 Queen Bed, 2 Twin Beds, 1 Queen Sofa Bed |

Dining and bars on site
Dining options on property cover breakfast through dinner: The Sagamore Room serves breakfast with lake views; Vintage Chophouse | Wine Bar handles lunch and dinner; The Inn Cafe offers deli-style grab-and-go items; Cabana Bar is poolside; and The Links Grille serves the golf club area.
Room service is available daily from 7:00 AM to 11:00 PM for hotel guests. The property operates cashless across dining venues and accepts major cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay, and gift cards.
- The Sagamore Room — breakfast 7:00 AM–11:00 AM, wall of French doors with bay view
- Vintage Chophouse | Wine Bar — lunch 11:30 AM–5:00 PM; dinner 5:00 PM–11:00 PM
- Cabana Bar — poolside service 12:00 PM–9:00 PM (weather permitting)
| Venue | Typical service |
|---|---|
| The Sagamore Room | Breakfast with lake views |
| Vintage Chophouse | Wine Bar | Lunch & Dinner, steakhouse-style menu |
| The Inn Cafe | Deli, coffee, grab-and-go |

Amenities, spa and wellness
The Spa at Inn at Bay Harbor is a full-service spa and salon located on the resort’s right wing; the spa menu includes signature treatments such as the Northern Luxury body treatment and the 75-minute Petoskey Hot Stone massage. Spa treatments are an additional charge and not covered by the resort fee.
Other amenities include a seasonal outdoor pool open through October with lake views, a year-round outdoor hot tub, a 24-hour Fitness Center, and complimentary bike rentals for guests. The resort fee covers enhanced wireless internet, valet parking, shuttle service within five miles, and second-floor washer/dryer access.
- Spa features: relaxation lounge, five treatment rooms, manicure/pedicure room and a retail boutique
- Fitness Center open 24/7 with treadmill, elliptical, weight machines and free weights
- Pool open seasonally (through October); hot tub open year-round
| Amenity | Notes |
|---|---|
| Resort Activities Fee | Includes enhanced wireless internet, valet, shuttle, washer/dryer access, kids' kits |
| Pool & Hot Tub | Pool seasonal; hot tub year-round |
| Fitness Center | Open 24/7 |
Family friendliness and activities for kids
Inn at Bay Harbor is marketed as family-welcoming: children ages 1–17 may stay free of charge when sharing a room with a parent or guardian. The property offers family-friendly amenities such as a private beach, seasonal pool with Cabana Bar service, bike rentals, table tennis, and kids' coloring kits included with the resort fee.
The resort lists a seasonal Kids Club (activities for children over age 5 are mentioned in travel listings), plus family-oriented on-site activities like ice skating in winter. For specifics on Kids Club schedules, ages, and any extra fees, confirm with the resort before you travel.
- Children 1–17 stay free with an adult
- Kids' coloring kits are included in the resort fee
- No adults-only pools or sections — pool and hot tub are family-accessible
| Family feature | What to expect |
|---|---|
| Private beach | Beach chairs and towels provided |
| Kids' activities | Seasonal Kids Club, pool activities, bike rentals |
| Winter options | Ice skating on property |
Who should pick Inn at Bay Harbor — pros and cons
Pros: direct lakefront location and private beach; on-site dining for all meals; full-service spa and 24-hour fitness; family-friendly policies and cottage options for larger groups. Many room types include kitchenettes or dining areas useful for families or extended stays.
Cons: the property charges a mandatory Resort Activities Fee that adds to room costs and some services (spa, certain extras) are additional charge; pets are not allowed in hotel rooms or Cottages (service animals exempt); the property is cashless so bring a credit/debit card or mobile payment method.
- Good for: families, couples wanting lake views, guests who want on-site dining and spa
- Not ideal for: travelers who must bring pets, guests on a strict no-fee budget, or those who prefer cash payments
| Consideration | Verdict |
|---|---|
| Value for families | Strong — kids stay free; larger Cottages available |
| Hidden costs | Mandatory resort fee and paid spa services |
| Pet policy | Pets not permitted (service animals allowed) |


