
Inn at Bay Harbor
Best for lakefront resort amenities, polished dining, a full-service spa, and an included breakfast for two.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Inn at Bay Harbor is a lakefront, full-service 4-star resort on Little Traverse Bay; it's for travelers who want private beach access, on-site spa and multiple dining venues. Apple Tree Inn, SureStay Collection by Best Western is a 2-star, value‑oriented Best Western-affiliated inn in Petoskey; it's for budget-minded guests who want simple bay views, an indoor pool and free breakfast.
Updated

Best for lakefront resort amenities, polished dining, a full-service spa, and an included breakfast for two.

Best for affordable, branded lodging with bay-view balconies, an indoor pool and complimentary continental breakfast.
When Inn at Bay Harbor wins: choose Inn at Bay Harbor if you want a private sandy Little Traverse Bay beach, seasonal outdoor lake-view pool, on-site full-service spa and multiple dining outlets — it’s a full-service resort experience for families and couples.
When Apple Tree Inn, SureStay Collection by Best Western wins: pick Apple Tree Inn if you prioritize a lower-star, value-priced property with bay-view balconies, an indoor pool and free continental breakfast near Petoskey attractions.
Bottom line: Inn at Bay Harbor is the better choice for an upscale, amenity-rich lakeside vacation; Apple Tree Inn is a sensible, lower-cost Petoskey option for travelers who want basic comforts, an indoor pool and breakfast included.
| Category | Inn at Bay Harbor | Apple Tree Inn, SureStay Collection by Best Western |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Full-service, polished lakeside resort with multiple restaurants and a spa | Simple, Best Western-affiliated inn offering practical rooms and standard services |
| Location | Directly on Little Traverse Bay with a private sandy beach | Petoskey address (915 Spring Street); within walking distance of local sights and Lake Michigan |
| Size (rooms) | About 115 rooms, suites and cottages (listing varies by source) | 40 rooms |
| Family policy | Family-welcoming; children 1–17 stay free with parents/guardians | All-ages property (not adults-only) |
| Pools & hot tubs | Seasonal outdoor lake-view pool (open through October) + year-round outdoor hot tub | Indoor pool and hot tub |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues (The Sagamore Room, Vintage Chophouse | Wine Bar, Inn Cafe, Cabana Bar, Links Grille) | Not published |
| Spa & wellness | Full-service Spa at Inn at Bay Harbor with signature Northern Luxury and Petoskey Hot Stone treatments | Not published |
| Known for | Private beach, golf access, weddings and resort amenities | Value stays with bay-view balconies and complimentary breakfast |
| Free breakfast | Breakfast for two included with standard stays | Complimentary continental breakfast served daily |
| Parking & shuttle | Valet parking included via mandatory resort activities fee; shuttle within five miles included | Free self parking on site; limo/town car service available |
Inn at Bay Harbor sits directly on Little Traverse Bay with an on-site private sandy beach and easy access to the Village at Bay Harbor.
Choose Inn at Bay Harbor for a true lakefront stay and easy access to local waterfront amenities.
Apple Tree Inn is located at 915 Spring Street in Petoskey with bay views from many rooms and balconies.
Apple Tree Inn is a convenient town option close to Petoskey sights and quick beach access on foot.
Inn at Bay Harbor offers a range from Standard Rooms to multi-bedroom Cottages and lakeside Suites.
If you need larger suites or a cottage and resort-level room features, Inn at Bay Harbor has more variety.
Apple Tree Inn provides straightforward room types with many options listing balconies, microwaves and refrigerators.
Apple Tree Inn covers practical needs—balconies, small kitchenettes and accessible rooms—at a modest standard.
Inn at Bay Harbor has several full-service restaurants and a pool bar to cover breakfast through dinner.
Expect varied dining options and in-room dining service at Inn at Bay Harbor.
Apple Tree Inn’s supplier listing does not publish signature on-site restaurants or bars.
Apple Tree Inn is best when you want a simple stay with breakfast included and self-catering options in-room.
Inn at Bay Harbor’s signature amenity is its lakefront setting with a seasonal outdoor pool and private beach.
For outdoor swimming with lake views and beach access, Inn at Bay Harbor is the stronger choice.
Apple Tree Inn highlights an indoor pool and hot tub for year-round use.
Pick Apple Tree Inn if you prefer an indoor pool that’s usable any time of year.
Inn at Bay Harbor has a full-service spa, 24-hour fitness center and resort activities.
If spa treatments and a full wellness program matter, Inn at Bay Harbor is the clear pick.
Apple Tree Inn offers fitness facilities and standard hotel services but no published full-service spa.
Apple Tree Inn covers basic fitness and business needs; for a dedicated spa experience, look to Inn at Bay Harbor.

Private sandy beach on Little Traverse Bay and seasonal outdoor pool with lake views.

Multiple restaurants and a poolside bar covering breakfast through dinner.

Complimentary continental breakfast and economical, Best Western-affiliated rooms.

Indoor pool and hot tub that are usable regardless of season.
Inn at Bay Harbor is explicitly family-welcoming with kids’ activities and children 1–17 stay free; Apple Tree Inn is all-ages but is more of a basic inn.
Inn at Bay Harbor has a full-service spa. Apple Tree Inn’s supplier listing does not publish a full-service spa.
Yes — Apple Tree Inn serves a complimentary continental breakfast daily.
Apple Tree Inn lists an indoor pool and hot tub (year-round use). Inn at Bay Harbor’s outdoor pool is seasonal (open through October) with a year-round outdoor hot tub.
Explore how Inn at Bay Harbor stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·