
Inn at Bay Harbor
Best for families and travelers who want a full-service lakeside resort with multiple on-site dining options, a spa, private beach, and event venues.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Inn at Bay Harbor is a four-star lakeside resort in Bay Harbor/Petoskey offering full-service amenities, spa, private beach and multiple restaurants; read this if you want resort-style lakeshore comfort and family-friendly facilities. Colonial Inn in Harbor Springs is a three-star, traditional inn a short town-block walk from Harbor Springs Beach; read this if you prefer small-town character, simple rooms, and a downtown Harbor Springs base.
Updated · about 4.5 miles (≈7 km) apart

Best for families and travelers who want a full-service lakeside resort with multiple on-site dining options, a spa, private beach, and event venues.

Best for travelers who want compact, traditional inn lodging in downtown Harbor Springs within steps of Harbor Springs Beach and local attractions.
When Inn at Bay Harbor wins: Choose Inn at Bay Harbor if you want a lakeside resort experience — private sandy beach access, a full-service spa (The Spa at Inn at Bay Harbor), multiple restaurants and bars, seasonal outdoor pool plus year-round hot tub, and on-site golf access and event spaces.
When Colonial Inn in Harbor Springs wins: Choose Colonial Inn in Harbor Springs if you want a smaller, centrally located Harbor Springs property with simple, comfortable rooms, complimentary continental breakfast, an outdoor seasonal pool and hot tub, and an easy walk to Harbor Springs Beach and downtown sights.
Bottom line: For a resort-style stay with more amenities, choose Inn at Bay Harbor; for straightforward, small-town Harbor Springs lodging steps from the beach, choose Colonial Inn in Harbor Springs.
| Category | Inn at Bay Harbor | Colonial Inn in Harbor Springs |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Full-service lakeside resort, resort-fee services, multiple venues | Traditional, small-town inn; straightforward lodging |
| Location | 3600 Village Harbor Drive, Bay Harbor on Little Traverse Bay (private beach) | 210 Artesian Avenue, Downtown Harbor Springs, steps from Harbor Springs Beach |
| Size | About 100–170 rooms depending on listing (resort with guest rooms, suites, cottages) | 41 rooms |
| Ages / audience | Family-welcoming; children allowed and family facilities (Kids Club seasonal) | |
| Pools & hot tubs | Seasonal outdoor pool overlooking Lake Michigan; year-round outdoor hot tub | Outdoor seasonal pool; 1 hot tub (listing) |
| Restaurants & bars | Several on-site options (The Sagamore Room, Vintage Chophouse | Wine Bar, Inn Cafe, Cabana Bar, Links Grille, room service) | On-site restaurant plus snack bar/deli and bar/lounge; complimentary continental breakfast |
| Spa & wellness | Full-service spa (The Spa at Inn at Bay Harbor) with signature treatments and multiple treatment rooms | Not published |
| Known for | Private sandy beach, resort dining, spa, golf access and event/wedding venues | Downtown Harbor Springs location, steps from the beach and local attractions |
| Parking & transport | Valet parking included in resort fee; shuttle within a five-mile radius; EV charging available | Free self parking on site; business center and luggage storage |
| Breakfast | Breakfast for two included with standard stays (The Sagamore Room hours listed) | Complimentary continental breakfast served daily (7:00 AM–10:00 AM listed) |
Inn at Bay Harbor sits directly on Little Traverse Bay with its own private sandy beach and easy waterfront access.
Pick Bay Harbor if lakeshore access and resort setting matter most.
Colonial Inn in Harbor Springs is in downtown Harbor Springs within a short walk of the town’s beach and shops.
Pick Colonial Inn if you want a downtown Harbor Springs base within immediate walking distance of the beach.
Inn at Bay Harbor offers a range of guest rooms, suites and cottages for families and couples.
Choose Inn at Bay Harbor for more room types and cottage options for groups.
Colonial Inn provides traditional inn-style rooms and a handful of suites geared to basic comfort.
Choose Colonial Inn for straightforward, well-equipped rooms in a small inn footprint.
Inn at Bay Harbor runs several on-site dining venues across casual and polished menus.
Pick Inn at Bay Harbor if you want a variety of on-site dining and a steakhouse option.
Colonial Inn offers an on-site restaurant plus a snack bar/deli and a bar/lounge.
Pick Colonial Inn if you want simple, convenient in-house dining and a complimentary breakfast.
Inn at Bay Harbor combines a private sandy beach with a seasonal outdoor pool and year-round hot tub.
Pick Inn at Bay Harbor for private beach access plus resort pool amenities.
Colonial Inn sits a short walk from Harbor Springs Beach and lists an outdoor seasonal pool and hot tub.
Pick Colonial Inn if you want immediate access to Harbor Springs’ public beach and beachfront town life.
Inn at Bay Harbor has a full-service spa and a 24-hour fitness center plus on-site activities.
Pick Inn at Bay Harbor if you want an on-site spa and a broader program of activities.
Colonial Inn lists a 24-hour fitness facility and relies on downtown Harbor Springs for evening options.
Pick Colonial Inn if you plan to spend evenings exploring Harbor Springs rather than using resort spa facilities.

Inn at Bay Harbor — private sandy beach and lake-view pool put you directly on Little Traverse Bay.

Colonial Inn in Harbor Springs — steps from Harbor Springs Beach and walking distance to downtown shops and museums.

Inn at Bay Harbor — a full-service spa with signature Northern Luxury and Petoskey Hot Stone treatments.

Colonial Inn in Harbor Springs — traditional inn rooms, complimentary continental breakfast, and easy town access.
Inn at Bay Harbor has a private sandy beach on Little Traverse Bay; Colonial Inn is steps from the public Harbor Springs Beach.
Inn at Bay Harbor has a full-service spa (The Spa at Inn at Bay Harbor). Colonial Inn’s supplier listing does not publish a spa.
Yes. Inn at Bay Harbor is explicitly family-welcoming with children’s activities; Colonial Inn is not adults-only and welcomes guests of all ages.
Colonial Inn — it’s located in downtown Harbor Springs within short walking distance of shops, galleries, and restaurants.
Explore how Inn at Bay Harbor stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·