
Inn at Bay Harbor
Best for a waterfront resort experience, on-site dining, and a full-service spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Inn at Bay Harbor is a four-star lakefront resort on Little Traverse Bay with private beach, seasonal pool, full spa, and several on-site restaurants — best for travelers who want an upscale, activity-rich Petoskey base. Super 8 by Wyndham Petoskey is a two-star economy-brand hotel offering basic rooms, free breakfast, and an indoor pool — best for budget-minded travelers and short overnight stops.
Updated

Best for a waterfront resort experience, on-site dining, and a full-service spa.

Best for low-cost stays with free breakfast, free parking, and a simple indoor pool.
When Inn at Bay Harbor wins: choose Inn at Bay Harbor if you want direct Little Traverse Bay access, multiple on-site restaurants and bars, a full-service spa, and resort-style amenities for families or a relaxing weekend.
When Super 8 wins: pick Super 8 if you need an affordable Petoskey-area room with free WiFi and breakfast, straightforward service, and an indoor pool without paying resort prices.
Bottom line: these properties serve different needs — Inn at Bay Harbor is an upscale lakeside resort with more facilities and food options; Super 8 is a national economy-brand option for practical, budget-conscious stays.
| Category | Inn at Bay Harbor | Super 8 |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Upscale lakefront resort; polished dining and resort amenities | Practical national economy hotel; simple, value-oriented |
| Location (town) | Bay Harbor / Petoskey on Little Traverse Bay (private sandy beach) | Petoskey (on US 131 South, shopping district area) |
| Size (rooms) | Approximately 115 rooms, suites, and Cottages | 60 air-conditioned rooms |
| Ages / audience | All-ages resort; children welcome (1–17 often stay free) | All-ages; not adults-only |
| Pools & beach | Seasonal outdoor pool (open through October), year-round outdoor hot tub, private sandy beach | Indoor pool; no private beach |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple outlets: The Sagamore Room (breakfast), Vintage Chophouse | Wine Bar, Inn Cafe, Cabana Bar, Links Grille | No signature on-site restaurant; complimentary on-the-go breakfast and vending |
| Spa & wellness | Full-service Spa at Inn at Bay Harbor with treatment menu, relaxation lounge and salon | No full-service spa published |
| Signature features | Private Little Traverse Bay beach, golf-club access, full event/wedding venues | Brand familiarity (Wyndham/ Super 8) and basic traveler conveniences |
| Free breakfast | Breakfast for two included with stays (property policy) | Complimentary on-the-go breakfast daily (7 AM–10 AM) |
| Parking & transport | Valet parking included via resort fee; local shuttle service within five miles | Free self parking onsite; limo/town car service available |
Inn at Bay Harbor sits directly on Little Traverse Bay with its own private sandy beach and walkable access to the Village at Bay Harbor and nearby arts and trails.
Choose Inn at Bay Harbor for direct waterfront access and a walkable Bay Harbor village experience.
Super 8 is a national economy-brand hotel located on US 131 South in Petoskey’s shopping district with driving access to area attractions.
Choose Super 8 when you want a budget stay close to Petoskey-area shopping and the casino.
Inn at Bay Harbor's rooms range from Standard Rooms to multi-bedroom Cottages and lakeside Suites with resort-level finishes.
Expect larger, better-equipped rooms and suite/cottage options suited to families and longer stays.
Super 8 offers standard economy rooms and a range of suites across a roughly 60-room property.
Super 8 is a no-frills choice with functional rooms and some suite options if you want a budget-friendly, practical stay.
Inn at Bay Harbor offers multiple on-site dining venues from casual to a steakhouse-style restaurant.
Pick Inn at Bay Harbor if you want a range of dining styles and reliable on-site meal options.
Super 8 does not list a signature full-service on-site restaurant but provides a complimentary on-the-go breakfast.
Super 8 suits travelers who prioritize low rates and a basic morning breakfast rather than full on-site dining.
Inn at Bay Harbor provides resort-style water amenities including a seasonal lake-view pool, a year-round outdoor hot tub, and a private sandy beach.
If lakeside swimming, beach time, and a scenic pool deck matter, Inn at Bay Harbor is the clear pick.
Super 8 offers an indoor pool for guest recreation but does not list a private beach.
Super 8 provides a heated indoor pool for basic recreational needs without the lakeside amenities.
Inn at Bay Harbor includes a full-service spa, a 24-hour fitness center, on-site golf access, and event spaces.
Choose Inn at Bay Harbor if spa treatments, fitness, and event facilities are part of your plan.
Super 8 lists basic on-site conveniences and proximity to local nightlife/attractions like Odawa Casino.
Super 8 is useful for straightforward needs and access to local casino or area attractions on a budget.

Inn at Bay Harbor — private sandy beach, lake-view pool, and direct Little Traverse Bay access.

Inn at Bay Harbor — a full-service spa with signature Northern Luxury and Petoskey Hot Stone treatments.

Super 8 — low rates, free on-the-go breakfast, free self parking, and a basic indoor pool.

Super 8 — recognizable Wyndham/Super 8 brand standards and practical room amenities.
Inn at Bay Harbor is directly on Little Traverse Bay with a private sandy beach; Super 8 is several kilometers from Lake Michigan according to its listing.
Not published — Super 8’s supplier listing does not show a full-service spa or salon.
Both include breakfast options: Inn at Bay Harbor includes breakfast for two with standard stays; Super 8 provides a complimentary on-the-go breakfast daily.
Inn at Bay Harbor’s outdoor pool is seasonal (open through October) with a year-round outdoor hot tub; Super 8 lists an indoor pool (hours noted in the supplier listing).
Inn at Bay Harbor does not accommodate pets (service animals exempt). Super 8 allows pets in specific rooms for a published pet fee (USD 30 per stay).
Explore how Inn at Bay Harbor stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·