
Inn at Bay Harbor
Best for beach access, on-site dining variety, spa treatments, and weddings.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Inn at Bay Harbor is a four-star lakeside resort with multiple restaurants, a spa, private beach, and event venues — read this if you want a full-service Petoskey resort for families, weddings, or spa-and-golf breaks. City Express is a midscale, 3-star hotel in Petoskey that fits budget-minded travelers looking for basic rooms, free breakfast, and convenient parking — read this if you need a simple base near Petoskey attractions.
Updated · about 6 km apart

Best for beach access, on-site dining variety, spa treatments, and weddings.

Best for straightforward, value-oriented stays with free breakfast and easy parking.
When Inn at Bay Harbor wins: pick the Inn if you want direct Little Traverse Bay access, a full-service spa, multiple on-site restaurants, seasonal pool and hot tub, and formal event/wedding spaces.
When City Express wins: choose City Express if you need a practical, lower-cost hotel with complimentary continental breakfast, free self-parking for cars and larger vehicles, and simple, accessible rooms.
Bottom line: Inn at Bay Harbor is a full-service lakeside resort for travelers who prioritize amenities and dining on property; City Express is a sensible midscale option for budget-conscious visitors who want basic comforts and free breakfast in the Petoskey area.
| Category | Inn at Bay Harbor | City Express |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Resort, lakeside, full-service with spa, multiple restaurants, private beach and event facilities. | Midscale hotel focused on practical overnight stays, free breakfast, parking, and laundry. |
| Location | On Little Traverse Bay (private sandy beach) at 3600 Village Harbor Dr, Bay Harbor/Petoskey. | 1314 US 31 N., Petoskey — inland Petoskey location near Round Lake and local roads. |
| Size (rooms) | About 115 rooms (resort rooms, suites, and Cottages). | 65 rooms. |
| Who it suits | Families, couples seeking spa/golf/dining, and groups/weddings. | Budget-minded travelers, road-trippers with RVs/buses/trucks, short-stay visitors. |
| Pools & beach | Seasonal outdoor lake-view pool (open through October) plus a year-round outdoor hot tub; private sandy beach on Little Traverse Bay. | Not published. |
| Restaurants & bars | Several on-site outlets: The Sagamore Room (breakfast), Vintage Chophouse | Wine Bar (lunch/dinner), Inn Cafe, Cabana Bar, Links Grille at the golf club, plus room service. | Not published as full restaurants; on-site grocery/convenience store and coffee/tea in common areas; complimentary continental breakfast. |
| Spa & wellness | Full-service Spa at Inn at Bay Harbor with multiple treatment rooms, signature Northern Luxury and Petoskey Hot Stone treatments, and a 24-hour fitness center. | Fitness facilities available; no full-service spa published in supplier listing. |
| Accessibility & family policies | Family-welcoming (children stay free), minimum check-in age 21 for primary guest; no adults-only areas. | Allows children (up to 3 children 18 and under stay free per parent/guardian rules); mobility-accessible room types listed; minimum check-in age 21. |
| Parking & vehicle access | Valet parking included via mandatory resort activities fee; EV charging available on property. | Free self parking plus free RV, bus, truck parking and off-street parking. |
| Meeting & event spaces | Multiple event and wedding venues (indoor ballrooms and outdoor lakefront lawns) with capacities up to ~250 for certain spaces. | Number of meeting rooms - 1 (small meeting capacity). |
Inn at Bay Harbor sits directly on Little Traverse Bay with a private sandy beach and close access to the Village at Bay Harbor and the Great Lakes Center for the Arts.
Choose Inn at Bay Harbor for on-water lodging and easy access to Bay Harbor’s shops, art venue, and waterfront activities.
City Express sits on US 31 N. in Petoskey, positioned for easy vehicle access and short drives to area parks and lakes.
Choose City Express if you want a practical Petoskey location with parking and quick road access to nearby attractions.
Inn at Bay Harbor offers a mix of hotel rooms, suites, and multi-bedroom Cottages for families and groups.
Pick Inn at Bay Harbor for room variety, family Cottages, and lake-facing accommodations.
City Express has straightforward guest rooms and a few accessible configurations intended for value stays.
Choose City Express for basic, accessible rooms and convenient in-room amenities like microwaves and free Wi‑Fi.
Inn at Bay Harbor operates multiple full and casual dining outlets for breakfast through dinner and poolside service.
Inn at Bay Harbor is the better pick if you want varied on-site dining and bar options without leaving the resort.
City Express focuses on a basic guest dining experience anchored by complimentary continental breakfast and an on-site convenience option.
City Express works well for guests who prioritize a free morning breakfast and quick, convenient food options.
Inn at Bay Harbor's signature amenity is its lakeside setting with private beach plus a seasonal pool and year-round hot tub.
If beach access and a lake-view pool matter, Inn at Bay Harbor is the clear choice.
City Express is a midscale hotel; the supplier listing does not publish a pool or private beach.
City Express does not publish an on-site pool or beach; use it for inland stays and access to nearby outdoor sites.
Inn at Bay Harbor provides spa services, fitness, golf access and year-round activities on site.
Pick Inn at Bay Harbor for on-site spa and activity programming plus golf and biking options.
City Express lists fitness facilities and proximity to outdoor recreation but does not list a full spa or nightlife venues on property.
City Express suits travelers who want a simple fitness option and to reach Petoskey-area activities by road.

Inn at Bay Harbor — private sandy beach, lake-view pool, and rooms with Little Traverse Bay views.

City Express — practical rooms, free continental breakfast, and free self parking for cars and larger vehicles.

Inn at Bay Harbor — a full-service spa with signature Petoskey stone treatments and multiple treatment rooms.

City Express — 1 meeting room and economical accommodations suited to small groups, drivers, and road-trippers.
Inn at Bay Harbor — it’s explicitly family-welcoming, includes children free-of-charge (ages 1–17), offers a private beach, seasonal pool, and kids’ activities; City Express is fine for families but is a more basic hotel.
City Express includes a complimentary continental breakfast; Inn at Bay Harbor includes breakfast for two with standard stays.
City Express lists free RV, bus, and truck parking on site. Inn at Bay Harbor provides valet parking (included in the resort activities fee) and typical resort parking but does not publish RV/bus parking.
Inn at Bay Harbor has The Spa at Inn at Bay Harbor (full-service). City Express does not publish a full-service spa in its listing.
Explore how Inn at Bay Harbor stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·