
Inn at Bay Harbor
Best for multi-day lakefront resort stays with on-site spa, seasonal pool, private beach, golf access, and multiple restaurants.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Inn at Bay Harbor is a full-service, lakefront resort in Bay Harbor/Petoskey with on-site spa, golf access, and family-friendly amenities; read this if you want a polished lakeside resort with multiple restaurants and activity options. The Earl is a stylish boutique hotel in Charlevoix with a compact downtown location and strong guest ratings; read this if you prefer a centrally located, design-forward stay for exploring Charlevoix and nearby beaches.
Updated · about 14 miles (22 km) apart

Best for multi-day lakefront resort stays with on-site spa, seasonal pool, private beach, golf access, and multiple restaurants.

Best for short stays in Charlevoix when you want a stylish, centrally located boutique hotel with easy access to the beach and town.
When Inn at Bay Harbor wins: Choose Bay Harbor if you want a lakefront base with a private sandy beach, a full spa, multiple on-site restaurants and bars, event spaces for weddings or groups, and family-friendly programming.
When The Earl wins: Choose The Earl for a smaller, design-focused hotel in the walkable center of Charlevoix—good for couples or travelers who plan to spend time in town, on nearby beaches, or catching the ferry to Beaver Island.
Bottom line: Both suit stylish northern Michigan getaways; pick Inn at Bay Harbor for a full-service resort experience on Little Traverse Bay and The Earl for a compact boutique stay in Charlevoix.
| Category | Inn at Bay Harbor | The Earl |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Full-service lakefront resort, multi-venue dining, spa and golf access | Stylish downtown boutique hotel, compact footprint |
| Location | Bay Harbor / Petoskey on Little Traverse Bay (private beach) | Central Charlevoix, steps from Charlevoix Beach and downtown |
| Size | Around 101–115 rooms and cottages (resort + cottages) | 56 guestrooms |
| Audience / age policy | Family-welcoming (children allowed; main guest must be 21 to check in) | All-ages (not adults-only); main guest must be 21 to check in |
| Pools & beach | Seasonal outdoor lake-view pool (open through October) + year-round outdoor hot tub + private sandy beach | Indoor pool and 1 hot tub onsite; public/nearby beaches within walking distance |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues (The Sagamore Room, Vintage Chophouse, Inn Cafe, Cabana Bar, Links Grille) | 2 bars/lounges and free continental breakfast; no named hotel restaurants published |
| Spa & wellness | Full-service on-site spa (The Spa at Inn at Bay Harbor) with signature treatments | Not published |
| Known for | Lakefront setting, private beach, golf access, weddings and events | Central location in Charlevoix, rooftop terrace, boutique design and high guest ratings |
| Parking & transport | Valet parking included with resort fee; local shuttle within five miles; EV charging available | Free self parking nearby; limited parking spaces and electric car charging station listed |
| Free breakfast | Breakfast for two included with standard stays | Free continental / free breakfast |
Inn at Bay Harbor sits directly on Little Traverse Bay with a private sandy beach and easy waterfront access.
Best if you want to be on the water and close to Bay Harbor amenities and trails.
The Earl is centrally located on Michigan Ave in downtown Charlevoix, steps from Charlevoix Beach and local shops.
Best if you prefer to stay in town and walk to restaurants, beach access, and local galleries.
Inn at Bay Harbor offers a mix of guest rooms, suites, and multi-bedroom Cottages for families and groups.
Better for families, multi-room needs, and travelers who want in-room space or cottage options.
The Earl has a compact roster of 56 guestrooms in standard, studio, suite and balcony configurations.
Good for travelers seeking contemporary, centrally located rooms in a boutique setting.
Inn at Bay Harbor has several named dining venues covering breakfast through dinner and poolside service.
Choose Bay Harbor if you want multiple on-site dining options and meal flexibility.
The Earl lists 2 bars/lounges and a complimentary continental breakfast but no named hotel restaurants in published sources.
Better if you plan to dine in town or prefer a short walk to local restaurants.
Inn at Bay Harbor emphasizes its private beach, seasonal outdoor pool, and year-round hot tub.
The resort is the stronger pick for lakeside swimming and beach days.
The Earl has an indoor pool and one hot tub, and is within easy walking distance of Charlevoix Beach.
Good if you want a hotel pool plus quick beach access on foot.
Inn at Bay Harbor includes a full-service spa and year-round fitness options.
Pick Bay Harbor for a full spa program and on-site activity options.
The Earl’s downtown location gives easy access to Charlevoix nightlife and galleries; an on-site spa is not published.
Choose The Earl to be in walking distance of town nightlife and services; spa options may require a short walk or reservation off-site.

Inn at Bay Harbor — cottages, suites, kids’ activities, private beach, and family-friendly pool areas.

The Earl — central Charlevoix location, steps from the beach, shops, galleries, and the ferry terminal.

Inn at Bay Harbor — an on-site full-service spa with signature treatments and dedicated facilities.

The Earl — smaller, design-focused property with rooftop terrace, bars, and high guest ratings.
Inn at Bay Harbor — it has multi-bedroom Cottages, kids’ activities, a private beach, and family-friendly pool areas.
The Earl — it’s centrally located on Michigan Ave, steps from Charlevoix shops, galleries, and the beach.
Inn at Bay Harbor has a full-service on-site spa. The Earl’s listing notes a health/beauty spa nearby but does not publish an on-site spa.
Inn at Bay Harbor has a private sandy beach on Little Traverse Bay. The Earl is a short walk from Charlevoix Beach and the Lake Michigan shoreline.
Explore how Inn at Bay Harbor stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·