
Inn at Bay Harbor
Best for a full-service lakeside stay with spa treatments, multiple restaurants, event spaces, and a private beach.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Inn at Bay Harbor is a four-star, lakefront resort in Bay Harbor with on-site spa, seasonal pool and multiple dining options — aimed at travelers wanting an upscale Little Traverse Bay stay. Bay Inn of Petoskey is a lower-priced, independent Petoskey guesthouse with lake-view rooms and simple, value-first amenities — a visible budget alternative for cost-conscious visitors.
Updated

Best for a full-service lakeside stay with spa treatments, multiple restaurants, event spaces, and a private beach.

Best for travelers seeking straightforward, lower-cost lodging with lake views close to Petoskey area attractions.
When Inn at Bay Harbor wins: choose Inn at Bay Harbor if you want on-site spa services, several polished dining options, event/wedding facilities, a private sandy beach, and a pool/hot tub experience tied to an upscale resort setting.
When Bay Inn of Petoskey wins: pick Bay Inn of Petoskey if your priority is lower nightly rates, simple lake-view suites or cabin options, free self parking, and proximity to local sites without resort pricing.
Bottom line: Inn at Bay Harbor is the choice for travelers wanting resort amenities and waterfront leisure; Bay Inn of Petoskey is the practical pick for budget-conscious visitors who still want Petoskey-area lake access.
| Category | Inn at Bay Harbor | Bay Inn of Petoskey |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Four-star resort with polished dining, spa, golf access and private beach. | Independent, value-oriented guesthouse with basic lake-view rooms and cabins. |
| Location | Village Harbor Drive on Little Traverse Bay (lakefront). | 2445 Charlevoix Ave, Petoskey; very near Little Traverse Bay. |
| Size | About 100–115 rooms plus cottages (full-service resort). | 15 guestrooms plus a few cabin/house options. |
| Family / age policy | All-ages resort; primary guest must be at least 21 to check in. | |
| Pools & beach | Seasonal outdoor pool (open through October) and year-round outdoor hot tub; private sandy Little Traverse Bay beach. | Beach access noted very close to the property; no published on-site pool. |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues (Vintage Chophouse | Wine Bar, The Sagamore Room, The Inn Cafe, Cabana Bar, Links Grille). | Not published in supplier listing. |
| Spa & wellness | Full-service Spa at Inn at Bay Harbor with signature treatments and multiple treatment rooms. | Not published in supplier listing. |
| Parking & transport | Valet parking included via mandatory resort activities fee; onsite EV charging and shuttle within five miles included with fee. | Free self parking is available onsite. |
| Known for | Resort services, weddings and lakeside leisure. | Value lodging with lake-view rooms and easy access to Petoskey-area points. |
Inn at Bay Harbor sits directly on Little Traverse Bay in the Bay Harbor area, close to the Village at Bay Harbor and the Great Lakes Center for the Arts.
Best if you want a true lakefront resort base with nearby waterfront retail and arts options.
Bay Inn of Petoskey is located on Charlevoix Avenue in Petoskey with very short distances noted to Little Traverse Bay and local attractions.
Good for travelers who want a simple Petoskey location near the bay without resort facilities.
Inn at Bay Harbor offers rooms, suites and cottages with lake and quarry views and family-friendly bedding options.
Choose Inn at Bay Harbor for broader room variety and cottage options for families or groups.
Bay Inn of Petoskey lists 15 guestrooms plus cabin and house options with lake-view configurations.
A straightforward set of lake-view rooms and a few cabin/house options makes this a value-focused place to sleep.
Inn at Bay Harbor has multiple on-site dining venues covering breakfast through dinner and poolside service.
Inn at Bay Harbor is the pick for variety and full-service dining without leaving the property.
Bay Inn of Petoskey’s supplier listing does not publish on-site signature restaurants or a bar.
Expect limited or no on-site dining options; plan to eat at nearby Petoskey restaurants.
Inn at Bay Harbor’s signature draw is its direct Little Traverse Bay frontage plus a seasonal pool and a year-round hot tub.
Pick Inn at Bay Harbor if you want a beach-plus-pool lakeside leisure setup.
Bay Inn of Petoskey is listed very close to Lake Michigan but does not publish an on-site pool in supplier data.
Bay Inn gives easy bay access but lacks a published resort pool and poolside services.
Inn at Bay Harbor runs a full-service Spa, a 24-hour fitness center and evening dining options for relaxed nights in.
Inn at Bay Harbor provides a full wellness program and evening dining without needing to leave the property.
Bay Inn of Petoskey’s listing does not publish an on-site spa or fitness center.
For spa and fitness services, plan to use Inn at Bay Harbor or local Petoskey providers rather than Bay Inn’s facilities.

Inn at Bay Harbor — private beach, seasonal pool, full spa and multiple dining venues.

Bay Inn of Petoskey — lower-priced guesthouse with lake-view rooms and simple amenities.

Inn at Bay Harbor — multiple indoor and outdoor event spaces and larger capacities for ceremonies and receptions.

Bay Inn of Petoskey — lists Bay Inn Cabin and Luxury House as on-site lodging options for groups.
Inn at Bay Harbor — it has a full-service spa with signature treatments and multiple treatment rooms. Bay Inn of Petoskey does not publish a spa.
Inn at Bay Harbor offers multiple on-site restaurants and a pool bar. Bay Inn of Petoskey’s supplier listing does not publish on-site restaurants, so plan to use nearby Petoskey dining.
No. Both properties are published as all-ages; Inn at Bay Harbor and Bay Inn of Petoskey require the primary guest checking in to be at least 21.
Inn at Bay Harbor includes valet parking via its resort activities fee and offers EV charging; Bay Inn of Petoskey provides free self parking on site.
Explore how Inn at Bay Harbor stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·