
Inn at Bay Harbor
Best for families or guests who want a full-service lakeside resort with private beach, pool, and on-site spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Inn at Bay Harbor is a four-star, lakefront resort on Little Traverse Bay with private beach, seasonal outdoor pool, golf access, and a full spa; good for families and travelers who want resort amenities and waterfront setting. Hotel Perry is a three-star historic downtown Petoskey hotel overlooking Little Traverse Bay; read this if you prefer staying in town near dining, the Gaslight District, and bayfront views.
Updated · about 4 miles apart

Best for families or guests who want a full-service lakeside resort with private beach, pool, and on-site spa.

Best for travelers who want a smaller, historic hotel in downtown Petoskey with easy access to museums, restaurants, and the bayfront.
When Inn at Bay Harbor wins: choose the Inn if you want lakeside resort amenities — private sandy beach, a seasonal outdoor pool and year-round hot tub, multiple on-site restaurants, a full-service spa, and golf access.
When Hotel Perry wins: choose Hotel Perry if you want to stay in the heart of downtown Petoskey with bay views, two on-site restaurants, free self parking, and a compact, walkable base for shops and museums.
Bottom line: both properties offer authentic Northern Michigan character — pick Inn at Bay Harbor for a refined lakefront resort experience and Hotel Perry for historic downtown convenience and classic bayfront hotel charm.
| Category | Inn at Bay Harbor | Hotel Perry |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Refined lakefront resort with resort facilities and golf access | Historic downtown hotel with bay views and a compact footprint |
| Location | Bay Harbor shoreline on Little Traverse Bay (direct lakefront, private beach) | Downtown Petoskey overlooking Little Traverse Bay (street address: 100 Lewis Street) |
| Distance between properties | about 4 miles to downtown Petoskey | |
| Size (rooms) | About 115 rooms (resort, rooms + cottages) | 75 guestrooms |
| Age policy / audience | Family-welcoming; children permitted and welcome | |
| Pools & beach | Seasonal outdoor pool (open through October) + year-round outdoor hot tub; private sandy beach | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: Vintage Chophouse | Wine Bar, The Sagamore Room (breakfast), The Inn Cafe, Cabana Bar, Links Grille | Two restaurants including H.O. Rose Dining Room; bar/lounge on site |
| Spa & wellness | Full-service Spa at Inn at Bay Harbor with signature treatments and five treatment rooms | Not published |
| Parking & transport | Valet parking included with resort fee; shuttle within 5 miles; EV charging available | Free self parking on site; concierge and tours/ticket assistance |
| Meeting & event space | Extensive indoor/outdoor event venues (ballrooms and lakefront lawns) for medium-to-large events | Banquet hall and meeting rooms available (smaller downtown event footprint) |
Inn at Bay Harbor sits directly on Little Traverse Bay with private beach access and waterfront trails.
Choose the Inn for a waterfront resort base; it’s slightly removed from downtown Petoskey.
Hotel Perry occupies a historic building in downtown Petoskey with Little Traverse Bay views from some rooms.
Choose Hotel Perry for immediate access to downtown Petoskey and a compact, walkable downtown stay.
Rooms at Inn at Bay Harbor range from standard hotel rooms to multi-bedroom Cottages and lake-view suites.
Choose the Inn for more room type variety and family-sized cottages.
Hotel Perry has a set of classic downtown room types from Economy to Deluxe lake-view balconies.
Choose Hotel Perry for straightforward downtown rooms and an affordable downtown footprint.
Inn at Bay Harbor offers multiple on-site venues covering breakfast through dinner and poolside service.
Pick the Inn if you want varied on-site dining and a lakeside breakfast option.
Hotel Perry provides two on-site restaurants and a bar in a downtown setting.
Pick Hotel Perry for a downtown dining base with easy access to nearby restaurants outside the hotel.
The Inn's key outdoor draws are its private beach, seasonal pool with lake views, and a year-round hot tub.
Inn at Bay Harbor is the stronger choice if waterfront swimming, a pool, and beach access matter.
Hotel Perry sits near the bayfront and offers bay views from some rooms.
Hotel Perry is a downtown option with bay views; specific pool or private-beach amenities are not published.
Inn at Bay Harbor includes a full-service spa, a 24-hour fitness center, and several evening dining/drink choices.
Choose the Inn for a packaged wellness experience plus multiple on-site evening venues.
Hotel Perry provides basic fitness facilities and a downtown evening scene within walking distance.
Pick Hotel Perry if you want convenient access to downtown nightlife and a simpler on-site wellness offering.

Inn at Bay Harbor — private beach, pool, full spa, multiple restaurants, and golf access.

Hotel Perry — in Petoskey’s downtown with bay views and easy access to shops, museums, and restaurants.

Inn at Bay Harbor — a full-service spa with signature Petoskey-stone treatments and multiple treatment rooms.

Hotel Perry — classic downtown property with a recognizable Petoskey presence and smaller scale.
Inn at Bay Harbor — it’s explicitly family-welcoming, has a private beach, seasonal pool, kids’ amenities, and family-sized cottages.
Hotel Perry — it sits in downtown Petoskey within easy walking distance of shops, restaurants, and the Little Traverse History Museum.
Not published — Hotel Perry’s supplier listing does not show a full-service spa, while Inn at Bay Harbor does publish a full spa and treatment menu.
Yes — both properties overlook Little Traverse Bay, but Inn at Bay Harbor has direct private beach access; Hotel Perry offers downtown bay views.
Explore how Inn at Bay Harbor stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·