
Inn at Bay Harbor
Best for lakeside stays, spa treatments, waterfront dining, and weddings.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Inn at Bay Harbor is a four-star, lakeside Autograph Collection resort on Little Traverse Bay geared to couples, families, and wedding parties who want spa services, a private beach, and waterfront dining. The Highlands at Harbor Springs is a three-star, larger Boyne-area ski, golf, and recreation resort that suits active travelers focused on downhill skiing, golf, and outdoor programs.
Updated · about 4.5 mi apart

Best for lakeside stays, spa treatments, waterfront dining, and weddings.

Best for downhill skiing, golf access, multi-activity outdoor programs, and larger-group stays.
When Inn at Bay Harbor wins: choose the Inn if you want direct Little Traverse Bay access, a full-service spa, lake-view dining, and a resort set up for weddings and smaller-group, polished-lakeside stays.
When The Highlands at Harbor Springs wins: pick The Highlands if your priority is on-site downhill skiing and lessons, golf and driving-range access, mountain-biking and snowshoeing options, or you need more room/condo-style lodging for a larger group.
Bottom line: both are Boyne-area resort options but serve different trip types — Bay Harbor for lake-focused relaxation, spa time, and weddings; The Highlands for active, multi-sport stays and larger accommodations.
| Category | Inn at Bay Harbor | The Highlands at Harbor Springs |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Upscale lakeside resort focused on spa, weddings, and polished dining | Major four-season ski, golf, and recreation resort with broad activity programming |
| Location | Bay Harbor (Petoskey) on Little Traverse Bay; private sandy beach | Harbor Springs; resort near Nub's Nob and local golf courses |
| Size / rooms | About 101–115 rooms and cottages (various sources list ~101–115/115 rooms) | 297 rooms (supplier listing) |
| Ages / audience | Family-welcoming; children stay free (1–17); main guest must be 21 to check in | Welcomes all ages (not adults-only); check-in minimum age 21 |
| Pools & hot tubs | Seasonal outdoor pool (open through October) plus year‑round outdoor hot tub | Two outdoor pools and two hot tubs (outdoor) |
| Restaurants & bars | Several on-site options (The Sagamore Room, Vintage Chophouse | Wine Bar, Inn Cafe, Cabana Bar, The Links Grille) | Three restaurants, one coffee shop/cafe, and a bar/lounge on site |
| Spa & wellness | Full-service Spa at Inn at Bay Harbor with signature Northern Luxury and Petoskey Hot Stone treatments | Not published |
| Known for | Private beach, waterfront views, weddings, and a full spa | On-site downhill skiing and lessons, golf course and driving range, broad outdoor activity options |
| Parking & transport | Valet parking included via resort activities fee; shuttle service within five miles included | Free self parking on site; a car is recommended for area travel |
| Booking note | Breakfast for two included with standard stays; mandatory resort activities fee applies | Cooked-to-order breakfast available for a surcharge; check-in at a separate Discovery Center location |
Inn at Bay Harbor sits directly on Little Traverse Bay with a private sandy beach and waterfront access.
Choose the Inn for direct lake access and a compact waterfront, walkable resort cluster.
The Highlands at Harbor Springs is located in the Harbor Springs area and positions itself around ski, golf, and trail amenities.
Pick The Highlands when you want a resort base for skiing, golf, and outdoor activities in Harbor Springs.
Inn at Bay Harbor offers a mix of guest rooms, suites, and cottages including lakeside Cottages and lake-view Grand Rooms.
The Inn suits couples, families, and wedding groups who want lakeside rooms or multi-bedroom cottages.
The Highlands provides a broad mix of unit types from standard rooms to lofts, suites, townhomes, cottages, and condos.
The Highlands is better if you need larger multi-bedroom units or condo-style lodging for groups.
Inn at Bay Harbor emphasizes lake-view dining and several on-site outlets from casual to steakhouse.
Choose the Inn for scenic waterfront breakfast and a refined chophouse option.
The Highlands runs three restaurants plus a coffee shop/cafe and a bar/lounge for resort guests.
The Highlands is convenient for on-property dining between ski days and golf rounds.
Inn at Bay Harbor centers its amenity set on the lake: private beach, a seasonal lake-view pool, and a year-round hot tub.
Pick the Inn for a lakeside pool experience and beach time when weather allows.
The Highlands emphasizes on-site downhill skiing and a full golf program alongside multiple pools.
Choose The Highlands if you want direct ski/golf access plus multiple pool options.
Inn at Bay Harbor has a dedicated full-service spa and year-round salon alongside evening dining options.
The Inn is the better pick for dedicated spa time and refined evening dining.
The Highlands focuses on active-program wellness: lessons, rentals, and on-site sport services more than a published full-service spa.
The Highlands is stronger for activity-driven wellness (lessons, rentals), while a formal spa is not published.

Private sandy beach, seasonal lake-view pool, and waterfront dining make the Inn the obvious choice for lakeside stays.

On-site downhill skiing, lessons, equipment rentals, and a free ski shuttle put The Highlands ahead for winter-sport travelers.

Inn at Bay Harbor's full-service Spa and multiple indoor/outdoor wedding venues make it a top pick for spa getaways and weddings.

With many townhomes, cottages, lofts, and a larger room inventory, The Highlands better accommodates big groups and multi-bedroom stays.
The Highlands at Harbor Springs — it lists downhill skiing, snowboarding, lessons, equipment rentals, and a complimentary ski shuttle; the Inn at Bay Harbor is more lake-focused.
Inn at Bay Harbor has a full-service Spa at Inn at Bay Harbor with multiple treatment rooms and signature treatments; a full-service spa is not published for The Highlands.
No. Both properties welcome guests of all ages; neither is published as adults-only.
Inn at Bay Harbor — it offers multiple indoor and outdoor wedding venues including a Lake Lawn venue and ballrooms with capacities up to the mid-hundreds.
Explore how Inn at Bay Harbor stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·